Days
Hours
Minutes
Make an impact through your donation to Deeper Walk! Give Online or mail your Check.
*NOTE: Checks must be postmarked by Wednesday Dec. 31st to be credited as a 2026 donation.
October 19, 2026

58: Act Like Yourself (Ch 8 | Rare Leadership) | S4E58

Audio Player
on the trail podcast logo
On The Trail
58: Act Like Yourself (Ch 8 | Rare Leadership) | S4E58
Loading
/

Show Notes

How do you grow your capacity to feel emotions without having them define or control you?

In this episode, we look at the second element of a R.A.R.E. Leader, the ability to “act like yourself.” We discuss three categories of leader: predators, possums, and protectors. The mature version of you will always be a protector. How do you develop the skills to be the more mature version of yourself? How do you grow the habits of acting like yourself? Understanding your true identity, managing triggers, and developing healthy routines can transform your leadership and personal growth.

The goal of this series is to equip you to live and lead with more emotional intelligence and resilience on your walk with God.

The book Rare Leadership by Marcus Warner & Jim Wilder combines theology, brain science, and decades of counseling and consulting experience to equip you to cultivate maturity in yourself and others, develop strong group identity, keep relationships bigger than problems, and more! Over the course of this series, we’ll be unpacking the four habits of a rare leader: Remain relational. Act like yourself. Return to joy. Endure hardship well.

Check out the free discussion guide for this book in the description links. 

 

📕 Rare Leadership BOOK: https://deeperwalk.com/product/rare-leadership-book/

🎁 DIY BOOK CLUB KIT: https://tinyurl.com/OTTDIY-RARE

💝 PAY IT FORWARD: https://deeperwalk.com/donate/

🙏 PRAYER MINISTRY REFERRALS: https://deeperwalk.com/ministry-referrals/

📸 Follow OTT on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/onthetrail_podcast

💚 HEART-FOCUSED COMMUNITY COURSE: https://deeperwalk.com/sp/heart-focused-community-course/

⚔️ IDENTITY COURSE: https://deeperwalk.com/sp/identity-course/

Go Deeper:

📚 The Pandora Problem by Jim Wilder – https://deeperwalk.com/product/the-pandora-problem-book/ 

Thank you for joining us – father-daughter duo Marcus Warner and Stephanie Warner – on the trail to a deeper walk with God! 

Chapters –

00:00 A Window of Gratitude & Anticipation

1:50 Act Like Yourself

6:03 Protectors, Predators, & Possums

14:12 Growing in Maturity

16:59 Triggers & Why You Struggle to Act Like Yourself

22:19 Healthy Habits

25:52 Redemption & Restoration

Podcast Transcript (ai generated)

(00:02) Stephanie Warner: Welcome to Season 4, episode 58. Hello, Father.

(00:06) Marcus Warner: Hello, Daughter. Here we are.

(00:09) Stephanie Warner: I’m so happy that it is still October. I’m a fall girly.

(00:15) Marcus Warner: Yes. Although November is your favorite month ’cause October’s still a

(00:20) Stephanie Warner: I’m so pleased that you know that. Thank you. Thank you for knowing that.

(00:25) Marcus Warner: Yeah. ‘Cause October’s still a little too summery for you, I think. So…

(00:30) Stephanie Warner: I love October, but sometimes October says, Psych, it’s still summer. And I’m like, no, no. I also don’t love the spooky season, all of that. And so I’m like, let’s just get into true, true festive holiday, true fall, true all the things. I love November Nano Rhymo.

(00:43) Marcus Warner: Yeah. Well in Indianapolis where we live, peak color usually comes the very end of October and largely the beginning of November. So November starts with peak colors, ends with Thanksgiving and it just is a true fall experience. So I get it.

(00:57) Stephanie Warner: Yes, it is. But I still do love October and it’s very nice. It’s very nice.

(01:01) Marcus Warner: Plus as a writer it’s like nano rhymo or whatever is that what it’s called? Nano Rymo.

(01:06) Stephanie Warner: Yes. Look everybody, my father knows me. I’m so pleased. But yes, so this is something I’m anticipating. I am anticipating November, but I can still be grateful and enjoy the moment, which is October. Yep. Yep. Well, hey, there was a window. A window into gratitude and appreciation and Stephanie, I guess. But today is all about Rare Leadership chapter eight. Doo-doo-doo-doo!

(01:37) Stephanie Warner: So, the goal of this series is to equip you to live and lead with more emotional intelligence and resilience on your walk with God. You can check out the free discussion guide in the description links if you are reading along with us, especially with a group that will be helpful for you.

In chapter eight, we are looking at the second element of the acrostic RARE. So, Rare Leadership, RARE is an acrostic, Remain relational. Now we’re on: Act like yourself. So Father, what does “acting like yourself” mean? I know the first time you heard that you were like, isn’t that a negative?

(02:11) Marcus Warner: Yeah, I’m like, No, no Yeah, ’cause you know right, yeah, most people I know said, hey, I’m just being me, we’re doing something really stupid. So what happens is people often have difficulty separating their false identity from their true identity, and they have adopted their false identity as their true identity. And so this can be a confusing topic. So acting like yourself, once again, we’re going to start with a brain perspective on what this means. And that means that I am living out of the part of my brain that thinks of itself as me.

So I’m going to be living from that joy center, the identity center in the front, upper right part of my brain, just above my right eye. And so acting like myself means that part of my brain is in control of my actions. It is, I’m running from that place, which is going to keep me relational and keep me acting like myself. So again, understanding the opposite of it can sometimes help us understand what this really is.

So when I stop acting like myself, I turn into a different person. And we can see this. So infants, for example, have no capacity to act like themselves. They turn into a different person with every emotion that they feel. And it is a skill that has to be developed over time of, how do I feel anger and not turn into the Hulk? Right. How do I feel fear and not turn into, you know, a cowering, you know, doormat? How do I feel shame? And not let that just completely shut me down to where I can’t function.

So the idea is, how do I grow my capacity to feel emotions, but not have them define me and not have them take over and completely control me. And so that’s a skill that we learn as we mature. So because, as we start as infants, we have no ability to deal with this. And if somebody goes their whole life and never develops this, then what happens is you can literally find yourself turning into a different person with every emotion that you feel.

And when that happens, people walk around you on eggshells, because they’re never quite sure which version of you they’re going to get, because they know, you know, if you get upset, you know. Sometimes we even threaten our kids with this as parents, like you’re mad now, you won’t like me. And when I, you know, if I’m really mad, and/or you’re scared, I’ll give you something to be scared about.

(04:45) Marcus Warner: Yeah, that’s scary because that means I will turn into somebody else, and you don’t want that to happen. So that is a really immature model. And so if I am leading people that way and I am coaching people that way, I’m leading my team that way, I’m essentially leading them with the threat of you won’t like me if I lose control of my emotions. I mean that’s about as immature as it gets.

So that’s why acting like yourself is so important. It creates stability, people know, you know, that they can depend on you. And it’s not that you don’t feel those emotions, and you can feel anger about what happened, you can feel disgust at things, you can feel shame about things. But you don’t, you know, just flip into somebody you’re not, and act with a completely different value system than you would normally have.

(05:38) Stephanie Warner: Yes. It’s like what Jim says, oh yeah, you know, remember that one time Jesus was so upset he healed someone? You know.

(05:44) Marcus Warner: Right, yeah. Yeah, Jesus looking around the room at the Pharisees got so angry he said, stretch out your hand, and he healed the guy. You know, it’s like he still acted like himself, even though he was angry at what the Pharisees were doing.

(06:02) Stephanie Warner: I love it. I love it. Well, hey, in this chapter, one of the things that you unpack is this concept of protectors, possums, and predators. And so our true self, you know, is when we are acting like the person God designed us to be, we’re going to be protector leaders, right? So I think in the book you go: a predator, then possum, then protector. But however it feels natural.

(06:33) Marcus Warner: If you want to flip it, that’s fine. So what happens here is a protector and let’s compare and contrast these. This is kind of what they’re there for. So a protector and a predator both excel at the same thing. And what they excel at is, they’re really good at tracking weakness in other people. It’s just that their motivation for tracking weakness in those people is completely different.

So a protector is tracking weakness in people so they can help. And they can add strength, bring their strength to the situation. So this will get us into a good Hebrew term, right? And that’s this idea in Genesis 2 when the woman is introduced as helper. All right, so what that means is the woman is bringing a strength to a situation of weakness or need. And so everywhere else that the term helper is used in the Old Testament, it is used of God. And that is God is the one who is helping us by bringing strength to an area of weakness. And that is the definition of a protector.

And so, in the same way, women can be protectors to men in their world, or they can be predators to men in their world, they can be possums with men in their world. And men can be possums, protectors, or predators. And so what we’re saying is that the mature version of you will always be a protector. And what that means is, you’re aware of weakness, and you’re aware of strength, and how your strength can be of help in a time of weakness.

So that can be a hug, right? That can be a listening ear, that can be giving guidance and firm counsel, that can be correcting somebody. So one of my favorite examples of protector leader actually comes from the elephant world. And it’s this idea that every now and then a young elephant that, you know, kind of like a rogue, teenage elephant, you know, suddenly is beginning to realize that they’re the biggest, strongest thing in the savannah. And they’ll just start tearing up other animals and vegetation just because they can. And left to themselves, they go rogue and they become quite dangerous.

(08:54) Marcus Warner: And so the herd of elephants, what’ll happen is some of the big older bull elephants will come and literally body slam this young, you know, teen elephant, and in their nonverbal way what they’re saying is we don’t do that around here, right? That’s not who we are and what we find is that when I define acting like myself, my brain learns who I am by understanding who my people are and how it’s like us to handle things.

And so if I’m in the category of mature leader, I look around and say, well, how do we, mature leaders, handle things? It’s going to be very different than how immature leaders handle things. And so that’s an example that always comes to mind of, you can be a protector by correcting somebody, and like that’s not how we do things around here. And you can be a protector.

The other thing that protectors do is they have the strength to stand up to the predators and to protect the weak from the people who are trying to be predatory against them. And so that can look a lot of different ways as well. So that’s what the protector and the predator have in common is they track weakness.

What the predator is doing, when the predator tracks weakness, is looking for your weak spot so they know where to attack. And they want to attack for a variety of reasons. Sometimes they want to attack just to make sure that they keep you in your place at the bottom of the pecking order, and they keep themselves in their place at the top of the pecking order, right? That’s one motivation.

Sometimes they attack because they want to use you for some reason, right? That could be sexually, but it could also be, they want to get something out of you in the workplace. And so they’re like, where do I attack them to get what I want out of this? Or to position you in a place where you have no choice but to do what they want. So it is like an act of war to find the weak spot and attack it, right?

And so that’s how predators think, and it’s sort of how they approach everything. And what it is, instead of being a protector leader, you become a predatory bully kind of leader. And I’m…

(11:03) Stephanie Warner: Could there be a version of that that would be like self protection? Like maybe they’re just like if anybody were to attack me, I would know all their weaknesses kind of thing or…

(11:12) Marcus Warner: Yeah, sure. There is that sense as well of, sometimes they do it out of insecurity, like I got to get you before you get me. Or if you try to get me, I’m going to make sure that I’m not the only one who goes down. We’re going to go down together. So yeah, there can be a version of that as well. There’s a lot of versions of all of these, but those are the core categories.

(11:33) Stephanie Warner: Okay, sorry. Continue.

(11:12) Marcus Warner: Yeah, no, that’s fine. The possum then is basically like the wallflower or the doormat. And the possum plays dead. Like that’s its one superpower. If a predator comes around. And so a good day for a possum is that they are not noticed by the predator. And so a lot of people like who grew up in a school where there were bullies around, for them a good day was the bullies didn’t notice them.

And so they learned to be wallflowers, they learned to be doormats, they learned to be invisible, and they know they’re weak, and they don’t feel like there’s anything they can do about that. And so they’re just going to try to be as invisible as possible.

(12:16) Stephanie Warner: I wrote down, possum leaders tend to disappear in times of crisis.

(12:20) Marcus Warner: Yep, and that is how that turns out. So sometimes possums come across as just really nice people. And so they get put in positions of leadership because they’re just really nice, but then they try to keep everybody happy, and they become people-pleasing, and they can’t say no to anybody. And when real problems come up, they disappear. And like, please somebody else handle this. You know, so that’s the downside of it.

And so you can have leaders who are all of these things. And I would say most commonly we see, especially power positions, tend to attract power people. And so the question is, am I using that power to protect, or am I using that in a predatory manner? And if I’m not in a position because of power, then I could be a possum. And that would be that I’ve just found myself here because I was the least worst option in some cases. Or I was the…

(13:22) Stephanie Warner: You’re really competent, but you know, kind of like when we talk about traditional discipleship and the kind of discipleship by osmosis stuff. Yeah.

(13:26) Marcus Warner: Yeah, or you’re really competent. Yeah. It doesn’t mean you’re a bad person. It just means that you’re not in that position because of… Yeah, it just means that the unresolved weaknesses there are going to cause you to abdicate at times when you need to really step up. And I will say that all of us can have all of these, right? So there can be moments where I turn into a possum. There can be moments where I turn into a predator, even if I’m primarily a protector.

(14:08) Marcus Warner: That’s what happens when our switch goes off and I lose my ability to act like myself. So all of us occasionally stop acting like ourselves, occasionally stop remaining relational. And what we’re after here is understanding, well, what is the goal? What am I striving for? What is it that I want to see happen? And then catching myself when I’m slipping into those other things, so that I can help to turn that around.

(14:37) Stephanie Warner: And that’s so much of what this whole series is about is learning to kind of shrink those gaps or build those skills or do the, you know, how do I grow out? You know, like I recognize in myself, I’m a possum a lot, but I want to be a protector, and this is part of how I’m growing. Or even, you know, like Jim’s book, The Pandora Problem, is facing narcissism in leaders and ourselves, right? How am I dealing with the predator inside? How am I correcting that?

(15:09) Marcus Warner: Yeah, no, and I think about that a lot. I got a memory of being in high school, you know, and so in high school I was like a three sport athlete. I was at the top of the class academically. There were very few places I would go where I wasn’t just automatically accepted because I had status in all the things that give pecking order in high schools.

And so, I realized while I was there that I was in a position to help people. That I was a strong person in this school and I had to choose, am I going to use this strength to get what I want, or am I going to use this strength to help people. But I have some very vivid memories of moments where I stepped out of that role. I lost it in a moment of weakness, because my emotions got the better of me and I became predatory. And so you know attacking somebody verbally was usually how that came out.

And so that’s why I say it can happen to anybody, and even if you’re primarily one way, we all lose it now and then. Again, Dr. Wilder calls this going into enemy mode. He and Ray Woolbridge wrote that book, Escaping Enemy Mode. And we all have these moments of stupid enemy mode, and that’s kind of what I’m describing. As there are moments where I got triggered, I stopped acting like myself, I did something really stupid, and to this day I regret it.

It’s like, oh man, I hope I didn’t do lasting damage to that person that I was so mean to. So you can be this way in other regards, but it tends to come down to selfishness. And that is, am I using my strength? So again, we could call this the Spider Man principle of rare leadership, right? With great power comes great responsibility. Yeah, that’s kind of what we’re saying.

(17:01) Stephanie Warner: I love it. Well let’s linger more on that. Why we struggle to act like ourselves and triggers and things. Like can you talk more about triggers and how to deal with them?

(17:11) Marcus Warner: Yeah, so for some of us what happens is, the number one reason that causes us to stop acting like ourselves is, we get triggered by something. And what I mean by a trigger is that I have an experience that gives me a strong emotion, that shuts off my joy switch, and pushes me beyond my emotional capacity almost instantaneously. That’s a trigger. And that can be something shocking, something, you know, that appears catastrophic, something that is angering or disgusting or whatever, but something, it elevates one of my emotions so quickly and to such an extreme that it overwhelms me, and I don’t act like myself.

Another way this happens is where I just haven’t developed enough capacity to where I live on the edge of overwhelm all of the time. And so I just constantly have a low level depression, a low level anxiety, a low level of anger. I just constantly have this as an issue and it just doesn’t take much for it to cause me to, it may be controlling the whole way I present myself most of the time. So that I’m just a cynical person or I’m just a yuck, disgusting kind of person, you know, who’s like always upset with something.

And that means that I’m not getting triggered. I have just kind of settled into a state of what I would call static enemy mode. I’m just sort of in that, that’s my static default setting for the way that I approach life. And so it can look a lot of different ways, but that is another way that manifests where I’m not really acting like myself. That is a false version of myself, even if it has become the default version of how I present to people.

(19:13) Stephanie Warner: Mm-hmm. Well, and I think, you know, you mentioned capacity, that sometimes we live in this age where we are so just at the max all the time. Just like, you know, we’ve got so much input, we’re expected so much output, and if we’re not sharpening our axe and I’m preaching to the choir here, if we’re not sharpening our axe, you know, if we’re not, you know, giving ourselves the space to do the things we have to do or to recover and, you know, rest and we’re just working all the time. And for leaders, that’s a huge thing.

You know, most leaders I know are just always to the next thing, always to the next thing, like having to carry all of this weight. And then you add the emotional, you know, weight into the things that just the physical tasks would carry. You’re going to get more easily triggered, because when you have just a little bit of capacity, because you’re constantly full. And so I think even some things like that, where like there are skill things to learn, and emotional things to learn, but sometimes there’s also…

(20:22) Marcus Warner: Yes, exactly. Because part of capacity is building a rhythm that you can sustain. And part of capacity is not going out of your way to build a lifestyle that is overwhelming. Sometimes we have things we have to deal with, we have no control over. But that’s all part of it. So capacity is kind of a two-way street, and that is learning how to offload unnecessary stresses and then input those things that are actually growing joy and growing things.

So one of the things I learned from Dr. Wilder as much from modeling and watching him as from what he actually said to me was, how much time he puts into hobbies versus entertainment. Like, you know, playing music, doing photography, taking hikes, you know, snorkeling, whatever it is. It’s like he’s very much into hobbies because those are life-giving, they make memories, they build skills, there’s some effort and there’s some satisfaction. Whereas just sitting down and watching TV doesn’t do any of that.

And so I realized that for me, my default for so long has just been I’m done, I’m checked out, let’s just sit down. And I haven’t built nearly as many hobbies. And it can be DIY stuff. And so you can take anything too far. And I know people who are workaholics with their hobbies and they’re not life-giving. So it’s not like just a thing like that. But I’ve noticed part of building that rhythm is building time for things in your life that are life-giving for you, without packing it in to such an extent that it’s just one more pressure that overwhelms the system.

(22:21) Stephanie Warner: Yeah. So at the end of this chapter you guys talk more about how to grow the habit of acting like yourself. And that gets into a little bit of this leaning on what we talked about last episode was the imitation and the intimacy and the identity groups and such. Can you talk about how those things work toward three elements of a healthy regimen that play a role in helping us act like ourselves?

(22:48) Marcus Warner: So part of what we’re after in building out a regimental routine is, the image that’s helped me think about this is Joy Camps and Joy Mountain. And the idea of Joy Camps and Joy Mountain is that kind of like when you go camping, you set up your camp and maybe I think about multiple families out there together going camping and they set up the camp and then they give some ground rules.

It’s like, okay, little ones, you stay with your parents. If you’re this age, you can go to the lake, but no further. Those that are this age, you can go out on the lake, but you got to be with somebody and you got to have, you know, life vests on. And then you adults, you know, just be back by seven, kind of thing. So it’s this idea of what is age appropriate, and let’s give people age age appropriate freedoms, age appropriate instructions.

And then you go out to joy mountain, and it’s like all right we’re all off here and we’re going to go do our stuff and we come back, and the only thing that really makes it for a bad day is if you get to seven o’clock and somebody isn’t there and they don’t make it back in time, and you’re like where are they? Why aren’t they here? Because not only do we want to be back to our settled place, we want to see all of our people, you know, back and in that settled place.

And so one of the things that leaders do is, they make sure that not only are they maintaining a rhythm and a routine, but they are making sure that their people have every opportunity to have that same rhythm and routine. What child-level leaders do is they have the rhythm and the routine, but it’s at everybody else’s expense. So everybody else is just working like dogs and they have a nice, you know, rhythm to life.

What Adult leaders and parent and elder level level leaders do is they’re making sure that everybody is developing a routine that they can handle. And one of the examples that always sticks out to me about this was Tony Dungey when he was coaching the Colts. And he was relatively famous for not keeping ridiculous hours. You know, he would come into the office, he would work, and then he would send people home. He’s like, guys, it’s time to go home, go be with your families.

(25:09) Marcus Warner: In a culture that was somewhat famous for burning people out, like you came in at six in the morning, you stayed till 10 at night, and you turned around and did it again the next day. And he took a very different approach, and yet his teams were winning 13 games a year, going to the playoffs and a couple of Super Bowls. And so I look at the same way that leaders not only have to have these rhythms for themselves, but they are making sure that they are not doing it at the expense of their team, but they’re helping their team build these rhythms as well.

(25:41) Stephanie Warner: Yeah. that’s so good. Well, man, we could keep going. Read the chapter, guys. There’s so much goodness here. I will just read a quick line that I had written out from it. One of the essential elements of redemption is the restoration of our ability to act like ourselves. Yeah, you know, Satan is the author of lies. He’s the one who, you know, gets us to hide and pretend and deceive.

And Jesus came to restore what God had made us to be. And so as we are growing closer to God, as we’re getting, you know, going deeper in our walks with God, as we’re growing in our leadership skills, it’s just a beautiful growth and a redemption story in and of itself. And I love that.

So thank you everybody for being here on the trail with us. It’s pretty awesome that we get to be with you from across the world. Someday we need to get on like a physical trail together. That would be amazing. But I love that we get to be on this podcast trail together. And thank you for everyone who supports us. We really appreciate you. Father, any final thoughts for this episode?

(26:56) Marcus Warner: Yeah, you know, I was just thinking about back when Jim and I were working on this book, I feel like a lot of what went into this book is Jim would say something that would make me go, wow, that is so profound. And I’m like, how do I work this in? How do I get this in and make this fit? It’s one of the reasons why I feel like every chapter in this book could be its own book. Like he could unpack this and turn it into a whole book. And that’s one of the things that makes us unique.

In fact, the publisher working on it said, one of the things unique about this book is most books have one core idea that runs throughout. This has like a core idea per chapter. And it’s very unusual in that regard. So I would just say if this is feeling like a fire hose and it’s a lot, it’s because it is. And it’s because there is a ton of content here. It’s meant to be a book that you read over and over again, not a book that you read once and go, okay, I got it.

(27:48) Stephanie Warner: Mm-hmm. And that’s part of why we’re here, to read it with you. Huzzah. All right, see you next week.

New episodes

We publish WEEKLY on MONDAYS.

Scroll to Top