(00:01) Stephanie Warner: Welcome to Season 4, episode 59. Hello, Father.
(00:05) Marcus Warner: Hello, Daughter.
(00:08) Stephanie Warner: We are interrupting our regularly scheduled programming for a seasonal episode. So we have been in the midst of a Rare Leadership series. We’ll get back to that next week. But yes, you were saying something.
(00:19) Marcus Warner: Yeah, we said, we interrupt this. I was like, Are the UFOs landing in New Jersey? Okay. Insider War of the Worlds reference from all the radio. Okay. Okay.
(00:28) Stephanie Warner: Indubitably, indubitably. Yes. So as probably you’ve noticed from the title or the thumbnail, this is the time of year when Christians are wondering about Halloween and how we engage with it, and the culture and all of this. So we just want to have a little conversation.
Producer Ben did do some research on some common questions that people are asking and I’ve got some thoughts too, so let’s get into it. Father, number one, just, you know, toss it to you, as I do a hitting, I don’t know. Actually, am I pitching? I’m pitching it to you. Okay, now you’re going to hit it. All right.
(01:08) Marcus Warner: You’re the pitcher. Yeah. Hopefully slow pitched softball. Go ahead.
(01:13) Stephanie Warner: Should Christians celebrate Halloween at all?
(01:19) Marcus Warner: No. Next? No, I’m sorry. Oh wait, what was…
(01:22) Stephanie Warner: When someone asks you this, where do you start? It depends on how cheeky you are.
(01:27) Marcus Warner: I know. Yeah, no, honestly, it’s a complicated question, and our family has approached this differently throughout our history. If you just look at origins, there’s almost no defense for the holiday, right? So if you look at it from other angles, there are modern problems with the holiday. So there’s a lot of problems with the holiday.
And so what you’re looking for here is, are there any positives to be had, and what are those, and how do you separate these things out? And yeah, it’s a bit of a sticky thing because…
(02:11) Stephanie Warner: And not just ’cause of the candy. Yep.
(02:19) Marcus Warner: Yeah, no. It’s because for a lot of people Halloween is just dress up, have fun, and candy. They’re like, what’s the big problem here? It’s like, and even if it’s a little bit spooky or a little bit scary, is that really such a big deal? I mean, and if that’s all you see in it, and that’s all that’s going on, you may kind of roll your eyes that people even have issue with the holiday. And so, I get that.
You know, I think that most people, their starting point is their starting point. And that is if they grew up with Halloween, they have happy memories about it. And it was one of their favorite things, because for a lot of people it embodies fall, and it’s the change of colors, and it’s the cool weather coming on, and it’s all of it, right?
(02:57) Stephanie Warner: It’s creativity and community and tasty things and yeah.
(03:05) Marcus Warner: Creativity and community and all these things. And yeah. So they’re like, Would you quit, you know, raining on my parade? I love Halloween, kind of thing. So I get it. That makes sense. And you know, I think that there’s things people do, and they just don’t know there’s a dark side to Halloween.
And then the question is, well, how much should the fact that there is a dark side to Halloween affect us as Christians and how we approach it? That’s really kind of what we’re getting at. So can you repeat your question now that I’ve gotten all that out?
(03:40) Stephanie Warner: So if somebody asks you, Should Christians celebrate Halloween at all, where do you start?
(03:45) Marcus Warner: I see. And I said no, right? So, like I said, we’ve been all over the board on this as a family, because there isn’t a strong yes/no on this necessarily. And I say that with a little hesitation because, you know, the apostle Paul did talk about meat sacrificed idols, and it’s actually, I think, a pretty good analogy. And he said, Let everybody be fully convinced in their own mind about it.
(04:16) Marcus Warner: He seems to indicate that he doesn’t care. Like, you know, if he eats food and he’s thankful for it, then he’s free to eat anything. But you know, some people who, if they find out that it’s been sacrificed to an idol, then they’re like, oh no, then you better not. And he says, well, so we don’t make them stumble. Let’s not do that.
Well, in a sense, Halloween candy is a little bit like meat sacrificed idols, because it is candy received in celebration of something that, depends on how you look at it. It’s either, oh, this is the celebration of the evening before All Saints Day, or this is candy in celebration of the high unholy day of witchcraft. And so you’re like, all right, what are we celebrating here? Has a lot to do with it.
And so no Christians, I’m kind of confident, no Christians are saying, oh, it’s the high holy day of Satanism and witchcraft. We should honor that, right? So I’m pretty sure no Christians are saying that. and I don’t think any of your neighbors are taking it that you approve of witchcraft and Satanism, because you are celebrating Halloween. So I don’t think you’re necessarily sending a wrong message there.
And so then you get to this question of, well, is it actually opening doors to demons if I do this? And I’ve not seen any evidence that like, you know, dressing up or giving candy to the kids who come to your door and thing like that is opening up…
(05:38) Stephanie Warner: Let’s circle back to that idea. Let’s linger on should we?
(05:42) Marcus Warner: There’s a lot of side issues that get into all this. So the question of should you or should you not, is not maybe as easy, or as straightforward as it sounds. I will say that there have been seasons in our lives where we absolutely did not do it. And it was because we were engaged with people who had had very traumatic things happen to them at Halloween.
(06:01) Stephanie Warner: Say trigger warning. Yeah.
(06:04) Marcus Warner: It was trigger, yeah. And so I won’t get into what those horrible things were that happened to them, but because of that, it would have been offensive to them to celebrate the holiday.
(06:14) Stephanie Warner: Yep. No, growing up we were lights off, blinds closed, just not dealing with it.
(06:20) Marcus Warner: We just skipped it. Yeah.
(06:22) Stephanie Warner: Maybe we’d go to you know, if a church was putting on a harvest festival kind of thing around that time, we might do something like that, but we would just skip the stuff.
(06:31) Marcus Warner: I think I remember taking you to Chuck E. Cheese once or twice, you know, like we’ll do something fun with you, and, you know, make sure that you have something, but we’re not going to do the…
(06:40) Stephanie Warner: Well, you’ll be happy to know that I don’t really remember that. I remember churches, so maybe we did go to Chuck E. Cheese.
(06:48) Marcus Warner: Okay. You don’t remember being traumatized by a giant mouse in a costume? That’s good.
(06:55) Stephanie Warner: I mean, I remember going to Chuck E. Cheese. I don’t associate it with Halloween. But yes, I mean the principle being. I think, yeah. Anyway, so what changed your mind later, you know, because eventually I went trick or treating with friends and…
(07:13) Marcus Warner: What changed my mind on it honestly was a conversation I had with our youth pastor when I was a senior pastor. And he’s like, Look, it’s the one night of the year that people who stay indoors actually go outside with their kids. And so if you skip it, you miss this great opportunity to be outside meeting your neighbors, greeting them, and forming a basis for future conversations, and all the evangelistic ramifications that that has. And I thought, well, he’s right. That makes sense.
And so if we engage with this at some level, then, in some cases, [it] was the first time we met many of our neighbors. And so that was the argument that persuaded me that maybe there was something to this. And since we weren’t actively working with people who were triggered by the day, you know, we did do that. And we continue to, usually we’ll make sure we have candy out, because it feels at this case like it’s just seen as a neighborly thing to do, and not as an endorsement of something dark.
(08:19) Stephanie Warner: Right. You know, I was thinking about this even as I like drove to studio today to podcast. I was like, man. Trying to think of other holidays or seasons or festival, you know, whatever goes on in the course of a year, at least in Midwest America where I’m familiar, where there’s an expectation that you’re going to go talk to people that you don’t even know.
Like most holidays it’s, this is time for family or this is time for friends or this is time for like we’re going to be, you know, we’re going to be extra intentional about getting together with our different family members or whatever at Christmas or Easter or things like that. You know, there’s Valentine’s Day and stuff, you know, or so I’m like, Fourth of July, there’s get out and be with people and parades and things like that. I guess if you go to Thanksgiving parades, you know.
But Halloween is this time where people are just expecting to like show off their creativity to each other, meet their neighbors, give candy, you know, and so I do see value in engagement and at that level of just like, hey, I don’t like spooky stuff. I don’t like celebrating like, I don’t like Halloween, but I do like engaging with my neighbors. I do like seeing [people], you know, and being like, what a fun Cinderella costume, you know, or whatever. Like there’s…
(09:40) Marcus Warner: Yeah. And that’s it, and it’s you know, the sad part about that is that, all of this creativity and community engagement is happening around something that almost nobody I know associates it with All Saints Day, right? And almost nobody I know associates it with Reformation Day. Like it’s the day that Luther tacked the ninety five theses on the door in Wittenberg, Germany.
So people don’t know why they’re doing it. And I also think that in a world that has lost the art of neighboring. It’s one of the few things that gets people out interacting with neighbors. And so that could be good and a bad, right? There’s always been a good and a bad to that, but it’s mostly good, I think.
You know, the flip side of that is, I go into certain neighborhoods and I just get creeped out by the neighborhood. Because they’ve got these giant, we call them giant Nephilim skeleton statues in the yard. They’re like twelve feet tall and they’ve got spiders climbing up their house and like they’re really into the creativity, but they got hands coming out of the ground and you know, it’s like they’re really pushing into it.
And I will be honest, every time I go into like a neighborhood like that, I’m like, I don’t like it. I don’t, and so I don’t know how much of that is just me, right? And how much of that is what every Christian should be feeling. But it is a real thing.
(11:07) Stephanie Warner: I have definitely gone through neighborhoods where I passed by and I’m like, oh, that was dark. Like there’s something dark there. And the big Nephilim skeletons usually crack me up. They don’t bother me, but that’s just a me thing. So I feel like some of it is in how it gets presented, and I don’t know if there’s an intent that you can feel with it.
I remember growing up, you know, you guys would even just like, We’re not going to drive that way out of the neighborhood, you know, during this season, because there are some really creepy, like gory, or just like intentionally scary, spooky thing, you know. I don’t like that. I don’t think that’s appropriate.
(11:54) Marcus Warner: Yeah, no. I mean people [in] our neighborhood, they put caskets in their driveway with purple lights and music and stuff. I mean, they really were like a TV horror show, you know, thing. You could tell they were really into it.
(12:10) Stephanie Warner: Well, and horror itself is just a very wildly popular genre right now. And I think yeah, fear gets a foothold and people like the adrenaline of things, and like to know that you know, for whatever reason. We could dissect that whole genre, but that might be getting a little off topic.
(12:27) Marcus Warner: Yeah, but it is true. I mean, I talked to a small group leader at a church who was actually an elder at his church, and he loved horror movies, and he was sort of addicted to the adrenaline rush he got from them. And you know, knowing a lot of people who’ve had doorways open to demons from horror movies, what I’ve learned is like what opens a door for one person doesn’t necessarily open a door for everybody.
(12:55) Marcus Warner: There are just other factors that go into it, because it isn’t in and of itself an active worship of the devil. And so what we know is forbidden is, active engagement in the occult. So like I may go to a party where people are dressing up and whatever, but if they’re playing Ouija boards there, it’s like there’s a hard line in the sand between being at an office party or something like that where you know, it’s almost mandatory to be there, and then pulling out the Ouija board or some of these more occult games that get played at some of these things.
And so that’s sort of where we draw the line. It’s like I will not engage in divination and in sorceries and spells and in actual, you know, sacrifices and rituals and things. So all that, there’s a hard, fast line there. The issue becomes like when you’re doing things that can be taken as affirming of that sort of activity.
That’s where some people are like, yeah, why are Christians even doing that? Because why would we engage in things that seem to suggest that we approve of the dark nature of the day. And I completely get that. That’s why I personally tend to lean into doing as little as possible with it but…
(14:22) Stephanie Warner: Yeah. So let’s linger into that idea of permission. So like the official question can costumes, decorations, or trick or treating open a doorway to the enemy? Where’s the line between harmless fun and giving ground?
(14:33) Marcus Warner: Yeah, I think the clear line is in engaging in occult practices. So let me just take this a slightly different direction. Sometimes for research, right, I’ve had to like look things up in the satanic Bible to see what they’re teaching people. I don’t get a demon because I, you know, did that. If I watch Harry Potter or something like that, so I know what’s going on with it, and I can talk intelligently about it, I don’t get a demon from doing that. There’s things that, just because I do these things, it isn’t necessarily opening a door.
Now I will say to be careful when I do those things, I will generally, you know, say if I inadvertently did, then I renounce it in Jesus’ name. But the clear line in the scripture is actual engagement. with pagan practices. And so the question becomes, if I’m doing things that are somewhat celebratory, if you will, or making light of these things, is that enough to open doors? And I don’t know the answer to that. I have not seen a ton of evidence that would say yes. But it wouldn’t shock me if here or there you would find a story of somebody where that did open a door.
(15:57) Stephanie Warner: Mm-hmm. That makes sense. Well, for sake of moving the conversation along, how do I talk with my kids about Halloween? There’s a lot of, you know, fear and death and supernatural stuff going on. And it’s like, where do you draw that line of, what do I let my kids do or not do? And how do I talk to them about it?
(16:17) Marcus Warner: Do you remember how we talked to you about it? I’m trying to remember. It’s been a few years since you were little.
(16:23) Stephanie Warner: You’re calling me old?
(16:27) Marcus Warner: I’m calling you millennial. All right. What is the…
(16:32) Stephanie Warner: I mean, Yeah. I think that for better or for worse, I understood from a young age that very bad things happen to people on Halloween. And I don’t remember specifically how that was conveyed. But I knew.
(16:50) Marcus Warner: No, and I get it. And you are in a unique situation because at the time we had somebody who had had horrible things happen to them on Halloween, who was very close to the family, and you knew this person well. And so we had to give you some reason for why we weren’t engaging with the day and all of that. And so it’s a little bit different level of conversation.
(17:08) Stephanie Warner: I don’t know if I’m a good example for this conversation, but I think that…
(17:20) Marcus Warner: Yeah. But I do think that, yeah, in general, what I tell people is, I try not to escalate or fear. And so if they’re curious about things, then I’ll say, look, Halloween has a lot of different meanings to different people. And what we are doing, right? Well, so you need to be prepared to kind of give a positive reason for why you’re doing what you’re doing as a family.
You say, well, we’re doing is, we’re acknowledging that like in the Catholic Church, this is a day for remembering the saints who went before us, and for those people who live particularly godly lives and honoring and remembering them. But that’s not what the culture is doing at large, and it’s not what most people are doing on this night. So we don’t want to, I’d tell clearly with the kids, we do not want to celebrate darkness ever, like do we? No. And we don’t want to celebrate evil or things that are evil.
But in the culture, people do dress up and they go around, they get candy, and they get to spend time with their friends and meet neighbors. So what we’re going to do is we’re going to pray tonight for all these other things, and then you can dress up, but we’re not going to be doing, you know, scary dress up stuff. You should just know that some people really love the scary part of Halloween, and they’re going to be dressing up that way, but we try not to glorify that. There’s a lot of different ways you can talk about it, but that’s one example of how I might do it.
(18:46) Stephanie Warner: That’s a good example. I also think, you know, again with just like the season and these days, man, people start putting up Halloween stuff, you know. Halloween stuff was going up in stores in July, I feel like, but you know, there’s a lot of this all throughout. And I just think, as Christians, man, read the Bible. The Bible directly addresses fear and death and the supernatural, and all these things. We don’t have to be afraid. We have victory in Christ.
We have a worldview that teaches about death, you know, and what it is, and how we can operate as Christians with an understanding of eternal life and all of that. We have a worldview that understands the supernatural. It is not, you know, for the most part, it’s not this big mystery spooky, you know, like I’m I’m afraid, you know, if you actually are understanding spiritual warfare and you’re understanding, you know, a biblical worldview that factors in those sorts of pieces, I think there’s a comfort there.
And I think for me, that’s another, you know, thing where maybe I wasn’t growing up with specific Halloween talks, right? But I understood from a young age that we were at a world at war, you know, hopefully at a child appropriate level.
(20:12) Stephanie Warner: I don’t know. I don’t feel like, it was like I feel like I was pretty, pretty grounded in, hey, there are things that are scary, but my God is bigger, right? There are things that I don’t understand, but God understands. There are things that I don’t have to be afraid of ’cause I have victory, you know, like and I think there’s something to be said for, you know, fairy tales and knights slaying dragons and things like that.
You know, like there’s the, we meet people in their darkness, we meet people in the fear. We meet kids, you know, in the, oh, that was spooky. And we bring them to hope, right? We bring them to the truth about the context in general. So I see that.
(20:57) Marcus Warner: Yep. No, that makes sense. And one of the things we tried to do as parents was to teach our [kids] not just, we do this, we don’t do this, but how to think critically about the things that we do and we do not do. And we’ve used this example before, but even when it came to Disney movies, we started talking about, all right, we’re going to see a Disney movie tonight, so let’s look at this critically. Let’s enjoy it, but let’s look at it critically too. What are we apt to see in a Disney movie, right? And we laid out five rules, five things to look for in this movie.
And it’s the same thing with Halloween. You can lay out, okay, here’s what we want to avoid. Here’s what we do. And why we’re doing it is that we want to build good relationships with our neighbors, and we want to use this as an opportunity to pray for them, and opportunity to engage with them, and to do the parts of this holiday that we think are innocent.
And then we will avoid those things that we think are crossing lines. And so that’s what we do. And so you kind of explain a little bit of this to the kids at some level. And then as they get older, you can explain more and more about the origin of the holiday and all the rest of it and…
(22:13) Stephanie Warner: Yeah, are you talking about a three year old or a five year old or an eight year old or a twelve year old? Yeah. Yep.
(22:16) Marcus Warner: Yeah, it’s like the difference between what you say to a three year old and a seven year old and a thirteen year old, right? There’s very different conversations to be had.
(22:25) Stephanie Warner: Yep. All right. Well for the sake of time, one more question. What if Christians I love land in a different place than this? Like how do we hold our convictions without judging each other? You know, how do we bring grace into this conversation?
(22:36) Marcus Warner: Sure. Well, I mean, we ran into this just a couple of years ago where our church wanted to do trunk or treat and we had some families in there like post online. My church has gone, you know, heretical, and we shouldn’t have anything to do with this, and blah, blah, blah. And I get it. So one of the things you do is first of all, your first step is not to post online.
(23:01) Stephanie Warner: That’s a good rule of thumb.
(23:02) Marcus Warner: Good rule of thumb is like you’re upset about something your church is doing or [something] your fellow Christians doing, your first step should not be to go and tell the entire world that you are upset with them. If anything, you should have an internal conversation and show some curiosity, and try to understand the other person, what they’re thinking. And perhaps if you go about this in a Christlike manner, in a more curiosity based manner, there might be a helpful conversation, and minds could be changed.
My mind’s flipped back and forth on this issue more than once, you know, because I fully get people saying, Why are Christians having anything to do with it? Because I fully get that. And I think I tend to lean that direction. But I also understand people who want to take advantage of the opportunities that are presented without crossing lines. And so you know, the best you can do is show curiosity and try to understand people.
And then at the end of the day, Paul kind of gives us an answer. Who are you to judge the other person? They’re going to have to give an account to God at some point themselves, and God will be their judge. So you can give people warnings and you can give them advice, but make sure you’re doing it from a heart that cares about them, and from with an adequate amount of curiosity as well, and then in the end you do what you feel strongly your convictions are leading you to do.
(24:29) Stephanie Warner: Mm-hmm. This is good. Hey, I’m going to link to the episode we did last year on this too. If people are wanting to marinate in the topic, that’s a weird thing to say. my brain is thinking things. So yes, I’ll post that in the description.
And yes, I just wanted to say thank you for everybody who was on the trail with us. Thank you for your support, for your encouragement, for your prayers, and your donations, and everything that you do. We are so glad when you join us on the trail, and that we can be with you weekly. It’s a privilege. So thank you. All right, Father. give us final thoughts on the episode and then would you also pray us out?
(25:19) Marcus Warner: So, you know, one of the things about Halloween is like, every year there’s a reason to talk about spiritual warfare. And it’s because once you get to Halloween, it is the high day for witchcraft and Satanism, right? Now it didn’t start off that way, I think it was adopted at some point. I don’t know the full history completely. I’ve seen about seven different versions of it.
But I will say this, that it’s a good time to remember to pray for our neighborhoods and to pray for our neighbors, to pray for our families, and to wrestle against principalities and powers, and not against people per se. And so I would just say, use this holiday as an opportunity to increase your time of prayer, specifically around the things that may be warfare related in your life.
(26:20) Stephanie Warner: That’s a good word. Will you pray for us?
(26:24) Marcus Warner: Yeah. So Father, we do come before you in the name of Jesus, grateful that Jesus disarmed the principalities and powers of the cross and he humiliated them and made a public spectacle of them, and led them in triumphal procession as his captives. And we thank you that all authority in heaven and earth has been given to Jesus.
And Lord, we do not want to glorify the darkness, or do things that cast Satan and things like this in a positive or even funny light, and somehow lead people astray. So we ask that you’ll give each of us wisdom in the way that we approach this experience, and that your spirit would speak to our hearts about what you are asking us to do. And I do pray again for both that wisdom and then for protection even from the things that we do in ignorance. In Christ’s name. Amen.
(27:22) Stephanie Warner: Amen.